HTTPS does not mean trustworthy – scammers encrypt too
An encrypted connection can lead straight to a fake login page. Here is what to check before entering your details.
“The site uses HTTPS. Surely I can enter my password?” That conclusion is dangerous. HTTPS protects the connection to the website you opened. Whether its operator is honest is a separate question.
My website hardening article covered TLS, the technology behind HTTPS. There is a distinction worth making: protecting a connection does not automatically make an offer trustworthy.

What HTTPS actually protects
HTTPS encrypts data in transit and protects it against undetected changes along the way. The browser also checks the certificate for the hostname you opened. An ordinary domain-validated certificate confirms control of the domain; it does not endorse the site's business or content. The Chrome security team explicitly explains these limits.
Criminals can register their own domain and obtain a valid certificate for it. Your browser may then transmit your password to the fraudulent site over an encrypted connection. The encryption works; the recipient is the problem.
One login, two different destinations
A completely fictional example: suppose your service used konto.example.com. A message instead sends you to konto.example.com.login.example.net. The familiar text is at the beginning, but the second address belongs to example.net, not example.com. Both could, in principle, use HTTPS. These reserved example domains are used only for illustration.
The names look similar. What matters is where you actually connect. A copied login form and a familiar logo do not change that destination.
Starting with Chrome 117, the old padlock icon was replaced with a more neutral settings icon. One reason was precisely this confusion between connection security and trustworthiness. Source: Chromium Blog.

Three things to check before logging in
- Read the domain carefully. Check the address bar, rather than relying on a logo or page title. On a phone, you may need to tap it to reveal the full address. Checking the name helps, but cannot guarantee a safe page on its own.
- Question the request. “Your account is about to be suspended” creates urgency. Were you expecting this request? Pressure is a reason to pause.
- Open the service yourself. If a message seems suspicious, use your familiar app or a bookmark you created yourself. Check there whether any action is needed. The UK government's Stop! Think Fraud guidance also recommends going directly to the organisation's website.
HTTPS remains essential. It protects your data in transit. You still need to check whom you are giving it to.
Which supposed signs of security do you encounter in everyday browsing? That is a useful question for your next conversation about phishing.
Editorial review: 3 November 2026. The linked primary sources cover TLS, browser icons and suspicious messages. Images: AI-generated conceptual illustrations, not browser screenshots.